Direkt zum Inhalt

Wie kann das Speichern verhindert werden, wenn eine bestimmte Zelle in Excel leer ist?

Sie haben beispielsweise ein Formular im Arbeitsblatt entworfen und mit Ihren Kollegen geteilt. Sie hoffen, dass Ihre Kollegen ihre Namen in die entsprechende Zelle eintragen, um anzugeben, wer dieses Formular eingegeben hat. Andernfalls können sie das Formular nicht speichern. Wie können Sie das tun? Hier werde ich ein VBA-Makro einführen, um das Speichern einer Arbeitsmappe zu verhindern, wenn die bestimmte Zelle in Excel leer ist.


Pfeil blau rechte BlaseVerhindern Sie das Speichern, wenn eine bestimmte Zelle in Excel leer ist

Um zu verhindern, dass die aktuelle Arbeitsmappe gespeichert wird, wenn die bestimmte Zelle in Excel leer ist, können Sie das folgende VBA-Makro einfach anwenden.

Schritt 1: Öffnen Sie das Fenster Microsoft Visual Basic für Applikationen, indem Sie auf drücken Andere + F11 Schlüssel in der Zwischenzeit.

Schritt 2: Erweitern Sie im Projektexplorer die VBAProject (Ihr Arbeitsmappenname.xlsm) und Microsoft Excel-Objekteund doppelklicken Sie dann auf DiesesWorkbook. Siehe Screenshot links:

Schritt 3: Fügen Sie im sich öffnenden ThisWorkbook-Fenster das folgende VBA-Makro ein:

VBA-Makro: Verhindern Sie das Speichern, wenn eine bestimmte Zelle leer ist

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean)
'Update by ExtendOffice 20220907
Dim xFileName As String
Dim xStr As String
Dim xStrWSH As String
Dim xWSh As Worksheet
Dim xWShs As Sheets
Dim xWSh1 As Worksheet
Dim xWB As Workbook

xStrWSH = "xHidWSH_LJY"
On Error Resume Next
Set xWB = Application.ActiveWorkbook
Set xWShs = xWB.Worksheets
Set xWSh = xWShs.Item(xStrWSH)

If xWSh Is Nothing Then

  Set xWSh1 = xWShs.Add
  xWSh1.Name = xStrWSH
  xWSh1.Visible = xlSheetVeryHidden
  Cancel = False

Else

  If Trim(Application.Sheets("Sheet1").Range("A1").Value) = "" Then
  Cancel = True
  MsgBox "Save cancelled"
  End If

End If

End Sub
Hinweis:
1. In der 26. Zeile des obigen VBA-Codes wird die "Blatt1" ist der spezifische Arbeitsblattname und das "A1"ist die spezifische Zelle, und Sie können sie nach Bedarf ändern.
2. Nachdem Sie die VBA eingegeben haben DiesesWorkbook, sollten Sie die Arbeitsmappe zuerst speichern. Und dann können Sie die makrofähige Datei an andere senden.

Wenn die bestimmte Zelle in der aktuellen Arbeitsmappe leer ist, wird beim Speichern ein Warndialogfeld angezeigt, in dem Sie aufgefordert werden, "Speichern abgebrochen". Siehe folgenden Screenshot:


Pfeil blau rechte BlaseÄhnliche Artikel

Beste Office-Produktivitätstools

🤖 Kutools KI-Assistent: Revolutionieren Sie die Datenanalyse basierend auf: Intelligente Ausführung   |  Code generieren  |  Erstellen Sie benutzerdefinierte Formeln  |  Analysieren Sie Daten und erstellen Sie Diagramme  |  Rufen Sie Kutools-Funktionen auf...
Beliebte Funktionen: Suchen, markieren oder identifizieren Sie Duplikate   |  Leere Zeilen löschen   |  Kombinieren Sie Spalten oder Zellen, ohne Daten zu verlieren   |   Runde ohne Formel ...
Super-Lookup: VLookup mit mehreren Kriterien    VLookup mit mehreren Werten  |   VLookup über mehrere Blätter hinweg   |   Unscharfe Suche ....
Erweiterte Dropdown-Liste: Erstellen Sie schnell eine Dropdown-Liste   |  Abhängige Dropdown-Liste   |  Mehrfachauswahl Dropdown-Liste ....
Spaltenmanager: Fügen Sie eine bestimmte Anzahl von Spalten hinzu  |  Spalten verschieben  |  Schalten Sie den Sichtbarkeitsstatus ausgeblendeter Spalten um  |  Vergleichen Sie Bereiche und Spalten ...
Ausgewählte Funktionen: Rasterfokus   |  Designansicht   |   Große Formelleiste    Arbeitsmappen- und Blattmanager   |  Ressourcen (Autotext)   |  Datumsauswahl   |  Arbeitsblätter kombinieren   |  Zellen verschlüsseln/entschlüsseln    Senden Sie E-Mails nach Liste   |  Superfilter   |   Spezialfilter (Filter fett/kursiv/durchgestrichen...) ...
Top 15 Toolsets12 Text Tools (Text hinzufügen, Zeichen entfernen, ...)   |   50+ Chart Typen (Gantt-Diagramm, ...)   |   40+ Praktisch Formeln (Berechnen Sie das Alter basierend auf dem Geburtstag, ...)   |   19 Einfügen Tools (QR-Code einfügen, Bild aus Pfad einfügen, ...)   |   12 Umwandlung (Conversion) Tools (Zahlen zu Wörtern, Currency Conversion, ...)   |   7 Zusammenführen & Teilen Tools (Erweiterte Zeilen kombinieren, Zellen teilen, ...)   |   ... und mehr

Verbessern Sie Ihre Excel-Kenntnisse mit Kutools für Excel und erleben Sie Effizienz wie nie zuvor. Kutools für Excel bietet über 300 erweiterte Funktionen, um die Produktivität zu steigern und Zeit zu sparen.  Klicken Sie hier, um die Funktion zu erhalten, die Sie am meisten benötigen ...

Beschreibung


Office Tab Bringt die Oberfläche mit Registerkarten in Office und erleichtert Ihnen die Arbeit erheblich

  • Aktivieren Sie das Bearbeiten und Lesen von Registerkarten in Word, Excel und PowerPoint, Publisher, Access, Visio und Project.
  • Öffnen und erstellen Sie mehrere Dokumente in neuen Registerkarten desselben Fensters und nicht in neuen Fenstern.
  • Steigert Ihre Produktivität um 50 % und reduziert jeden Tag Hunderte von Mausklicks für Sie!
Comments (26)
No ratings yet. Be the first to rate!
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Ciao,
io avrei bisogno di impostare una macro simile a quella di Eduardo. In particolare, ho due tabelle:
'- prima tabella A18:P28
'- seconda tabella A33:P41.
Vorrei impedire che l'utente salvi il file se ha compilato la cella A18 e le altre attigue (B18:P18) le ha lasciate vuote oppure se ha compilato la cella A33 e ha lasciato vuole le attigue (B33:P33). In questo caso, come dovrei impostare la macro? Grazie in anticipo a chi risponderà!
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Hi there,

Do you mean that you want to prevent from saving the file if A18 is filled while B18: P18 are blank? You also want to prevent from saving if A33 is filled while B33: P33 are blank?
Do you want to prevent from saving when both criteria are met, or when either of the criteria is met?
Also, please use English. Thanks in advance.

Amanda
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
This is not working, it states save cancelled but still ends up saving the workbook
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Note: In the VBA code, the "TEST" is the specific worksheet name, and the "A1" is the specific cell, and you can change them as you need.

For example, your sheet is named as "Sheet1", and the specified cell is B2, you need to change the sheet name and cell address in the VBA code before running it
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
I tried above formula which works. May i know is there any formula can force user to fill in before they can save? As i set the pull down menu "Please select", "Yes" or "No" for them to select. But they always forgot to select that field and remain "Please select". If i add this VBA code only apply cell is blank. Much appreciate you can advise. Thank you
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Hi Happy,
Just replace the empty value “Sheets("TEST").Range("A1").Value = ""” to the specified text “Sheets("TEST").Range("A1").Value = "Please select"”And the whole code will be changed as below:
<div data-tag="code">Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean)
If Application.Sheets("TEST").Range("A1").Value = "Please select" Then
Cancel = True
MsgBox "Save cancelled"
End If
End Sub

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Hi, I tried above formula which works. May i know is there any formula can force user to fill in before they can save? As i set the pull down menu "Please select", "Yes" or "No" for them to select. But they always forgot to select that field and remain "Please select". If i add this VBA code only apply cell is blank. Much appreciate you can advise. Thank you
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Hi
I have a VBA code that sorts and filters data from one excel table and save 48 different reports on my desktop. but based on those filters, some generated reports have only 1 row (headers) and no data. How can I add some VBA code to my file that prevents to save files that has just one row (header) and no data?
Thank you
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
HiI have a VBA code that sorts and filters data from one excel table and save 48 different reports on my desktop. but based on those filters, some generated reports have only 1 row (headers) and no data. How can I add some VBA code to my file that prevents to save files that has just one row (header) and no data?Thank you
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
good afternoon, I used the code above and it worked perfectly. my question is what should the code look like if I want to test on 2 cells? I am quite desperate. thanking you I advance for your assistance
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
I have a very big spreadsheet that contains a lot of info.
Can someone please help me with a code to copy into VBA - I want it to be that if Cell C2-C1000+ have any info in them then cell O2-O1000+ and P2-P1000+ requires user input - however if a cell in Column C is empty then the cell in Column O & P can be empty as well. (for example) if cell C3 doesn't have any data input then cell O3-P3 can be empty.

Thank you :)
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Hi Yzelle,
Please remember to place below code into “ThisWorkbook” script window, and rename the worksheet name “Test” in the below code based on your condition.

Dim xIRg As Range
Dim xSRg As Range
Dim xBol As Boolean
Dim xInt As Integer
Dim xStr As String
If ActiveSheet.Name = "Test" Then
Set xRg = Range("C:C")
Set xRRg = Intersect(xRg.Worksheet.UsedRange, xRg)
xBol = False
On Error Resume Next
For xInt = 1 To xRRg.Count
Set xIRg = xRRg.Item(xInt)
If xIRg.Value2 <> "" Then
Set xSRg = Nothing
If (Range("O" & xIRg.Row) = "") Or (Range("P" & xIRg.Row) = "") Then
xBol = True
Exit For
End If
End If
Next
If xBol Then
Cancel = True
MsgBox "Save cancelled"
End If
End If
End Sub
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean)

With Sheets("Sheet1")
If WorksheetFunction.CountA(.Range("A1:A4")) <> WorksheetFunction.CountA(.Range("B1:C4")) / 2 Then
Cancel = True
MsgBox "Please enter a values in columns B and C", vbCritical, "Error!"
End If
End With

End Sub


Just change the range from a to c, and from b to o and p
hope it will help
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean)

With Sheets("Sheet1")
If WorksheetFunction.CountA(.Range("A1:A4")) <> WorksheetFunction.CountA(.Range("B1:C4")) / 2 Then
Cancel = True
MsgBox "Please enter a values in columns B and C", vbCritical, "Error!"
End If
End With

End Sub

Just change the range from a to c, and from b to o and phope it will help
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Do you have a way that this can be coded so that either B or C need to be populated but its not required to populate both?
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
This is really great. Do you know what I can do to make this work for a range of sheets and a number of cells? Also, these cells cannot always be the same, as there are sheets generated in this specific workbook which may not have the same cell needing to be filled each time. The cells will always be in the same column, just above the page border which is also generated. Thanks!
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site
Hi, very useful. BUT there is a problem when I use it for files on the sharepoint. The changes are not saved but a new version is created that is displayed when reopening which is quite confusing. Is it possible to disable these new versions ?
There are no comments posted here yet
Load More
Please leave your comments in English
Posting as Guest
×
Rate this post:
0   Characters
Suggested Locations